the author has a certain experience in the field. The work needs to be submitted as an experience not reporting his work as he writes: this report .......

It is a report documenting a certain work without new point of view or experiences.

It is a typical GIS work and excersice not an outstanding one.
it is up to you to accept or refuse such a paper.
As i ticked the (Marginal Tend to Accept:) to give the author a chance to modify work.
