1. The case study does not show clear advantages of using a specific simulation tool rather than using another one.

2. The Light planning part is well introduced.

3. The research, in the simulation tools part 3, is just a shallow explanation of the capabilities of simulation tools that any user knows. Such capabilities, regardless their limitations, are listed clearly in such software’s manuals and tutorials as well.  

4. It would be useful if the case study in hand showed some achievements or even drawbacks that would help in developing the software. On the other hand a "push over the limits" of the simulation tools to support decision making in lighting design would be appreciated as well.
